Tuile typographique : je n'ai jamais mis les pieds dans une ferme de café

I have never set foot in a coffee farm

TL;DR: I have never visited a coffee farm, and I do not do “direct trade.” I buy my green coffee from specialty importers who document the farm, producer, variety, and processing method, and I taste a roasted sample before making any purchase. For a micro-roastery, this is the most honest supply chain I know.

A roaster who buys through an importer is no less traceable than a roaster who travels: traceability is found in the lot sheet, not in the photo. I’ll explain how I buy coffee and why I don’t tell stories about farms I have never visited.

Direct trade: the photo at the farm, and what it doesn’t tell you

You know the image: the roaster in a button-down shirt, holding a coffee branch, with the producer standing beside them. I don’t disparage those who do this. Going to the origin and building a relationship with a farm over several harvests is real work, and some people do it seriously. But this image has become a marketing trope, and tropes are easy to copy. A trip guarantees neither the quality of the green coffee in the bag nor the consistency of the lot from one year to the next.

And above all, I simply cannot do it. A micro-roastery buys by the bag, sometimes just a few kilos to test a lot. A farm does not organize itself for that, and I have neither the time nor the volume to justify a round trip to Colombia or Rwanda. Saying so is already more honest than implying it.

What a specialty importer does that I cannot do

My suppliers, mainly Mare Terra and 88 Graines, have a skill I do not: selecting green coffee at the origin, importing it, storing it properly, and documenting it. Every lot arrives with its own sheet: country, region, farm or cooperative, producer, variety, processing method, altitude, harvest year, flavor descriptors, and score. This is the sheet I copy onto my product pages, and most of its information (country, farm, variety, processing method) appears on my bag labels. When I write a producer’s name, it comes from there, and I can show you where it came from.

The importer tastes and compares lots all year round. I do so with just a few. Their expertise in green coffee is real; mine is in roasting and the cup. We each have our own role: that is how I can offer you several consistent origins without making up stories. The details of my purchasing method are in the article “How I Buy My Green Coffee”.

The sheet is not enough: I taste before buying

Trusting the importer does not mean buying from a catalog. Trade scores are often inflated—Scott Rao has documented this—and a flattering sheet says nothing about the lot’s defects. So I roast a sample and taste it before ordering a bag, using two safeguards that I explain elsewhere: the harvest year and the interpretation of the flavor descriptors. For a sheet-by-sheet breakdown, the complete method is in “How I Buy My Green Coffee”. The question this article addresses is different: does buying through an importer rather than doing direct trade cause you to lose out on traceability or quality in the cup? No, and the following sections show why.

What the score means and what it does not guarantee is explained in the article on SCA scores. And what makes a coffee “specialty” beyond the number is explained here.

What this means for you

Nothing in terms of traceability: you have the country, farm, producer, variety, and processing method on the sheet for each of my single origins. What does change is the narrative. I am not selling you a friendship with a producer I have never met. I am selling you green coffee selected by people whose job it is, tasted by me before it is purchased, and light-to-medium roasted in small batches. If I ever go to the origin, I will tell you. Not before.

Frequently asked questions

Is a roaster who buys through an importer less traceable?

No. A specialty importer provides the farm or cooperative, producer, variety, processing method, altitude, and harvest year for every lot. Traceability is found in this sheet, which the roaster includes on their product pages and, for the most part, on their bag labels. A trip to the origin can build a relationship and allow for on-site verification; it replaces neither the lot sheet nor the cup.

Why doesn’t a micro-roastery do direct trade?

It is a matter of volume. A micro-roastery buys by the bag, sometimes just a few kilos to test a lot. A farm does not organize itself for such small quantities, and the cost of a trip cannot be justified. The importer consolidates volumes, imports, stores, and documents: that is their job, not the roaster’s.

What is direct trade, and why don’t I do it?

Direct trade refers to a roaster who buys their green coffee through a direct relationship with a farm, without an importer. It is not a label: it has no standardized definition or certification, and every brand can use it however it likes. I do not do it because of volume: I buy by the bag, and a farm does not organize itself for that. I work with specialty importers who document every lot, and I taste a roasted sample before buying. The purchasing method itself is detailed in the article “How I Buy My Green Coffee.”

Should you be wary of roasters who travel to the origin?

No, but you should look beyond the photo. Some build genuine relationships with a farm over several harvests. What matters to the buyer is the lot sheet and the cup: a trip guarantees neither the quality of the green coffee nor its consistency from one year to the next.

Back to blog